May 21, 2012
11
reviews
Rate & Review

Apple Cider Levain Loaf

Tart and tangy with apple cider and dried cranberries, this flavorful, naturally leavened white bread can also be made without those ingredients; simply substitute the same amount of water for the apple cider and omit the cranberries. This recipe first appeared in our May 2012 issue along with William Alexander's story American Bread.
Print Save Recipe
Apple Cider Levain Loaf Enlarge Image Credit: Todd Coleman

INGREDIENTS

6 ½ cups plus ⅓ cup (3 lb. 6 ⅔ oz.) tap water, heated to 115°
¼ tsp. active dry yeast
4 ¾ cups plus ⅔ cup and 2 tbsp. (1 lb. 9 ⅓ oz.) all-purpose flour
4 cups (1 lb. 4 oz.) bread flour
1 cup (8 oz.) apple cider, at room temperature
½ cup (2 oz.) dried cranberries
2 tsp. (½ oz.) kosher salt Canola oil, for greasing
½ cup ice cubes

INSTRUCTIONS

1. In a large bowl, stir together ⅔ cup water, ¼ cup plus 2 tbsp. all-purpose flour, and yeast until a smooth paste forms; cover with plastic wrap, and let sit for 24 hours. Repeat this process for the next eight days, adding ⅓ cup each water and flour the second and third days and ¾ cup the remaining days, to make the starter (which you can keep alive, in the fridge, by adding the same amounts once weekly.)

 
2. On the 10th day, place ¼ cup starter in a bowl and stir in ⅓ cup water, ¾ cup bread flour, and ¼ cup apple cider to create sourdough culture (Figure A); let sit for 12–24 hours, until ready to bake.

3. Uncover culture and add remaining ⅔ cup water, 3 ¼ cups bread flour, ¾ cup cider, along with cranberries and salt (Figure B). Stir until dough forms (Figure C); let dough sit to let flour hydrate, about 20 minutes. Transfer dough to a floured surface, and knead, using a bench scraper to help remove dough from surface, until smooth and elastic, about 10 minutes. Transfer to a greased bowl; cover with plastic wrap, and place in a cold oven. Let rest until slightly inflated, about 1 hour. Transfer dough to a floured surface and flatten slightly. Fold top and bottom edges toward middle. Return dough, seam side down, to bowl (Figure D); cover. Let sit until doubled in size, about 3 hours.

4. Repeat folding procedure, and place dough, seam side down, into a greased 8″ x 5″ x 2 ½″ loaf pan, cover with plastic again, and return to oven. Let sit until dough reaches top of the loaf pan, about 3 hours. One hour before baking, place a cast–iron skillet on bottom rack of oven; position another rack above skillet; place a baking stone on top of it. Heat oven to 475°.

5. Using a razor, slash top of loaf at a 30° angle in four spots. Place loaf on baking stone; place ice in skillet. Bake until brown, about 50 minutes; let cool before serving.

Apple Cider Levain Loaf

This article was first published in Saveur in Issue #147

Ratings & Reviews (11)

I'm confused about the starter. Most tarter recipes,call for you to throw out all but a bit on days 3-8 so you can add more. Otherwise you end up with a ton of starter of which you are only going to use 1/4 cup.......anyone else thinking this? I'm only in the starter phas of this recipe.......
I agree. It's also unclear as to the additional amounts needed to keep the starter alive after the initial batch. I haven't started it yet but it sounds like it might be enough starter for 15+ loaves.
Okay, as far as I've figured it, for this to be starter for one loaf you have to take out all but a tablespoon or two before you add the next day's amount. Or, like another said, be prepared to make a dozen loaves. Again still in the starter phase here.
Thank you, LKYMOM! I was just as confused as you. I bake a ton and have for years, but have never created a starter and found these directions quite vague. I've followed the recipe to my best ability and now have about a quart of starter, which is enough for 16 loaves of this bread...that's if I baked today. If I keep feeding it without discarding any, it'll soon fill my fridge! :-) I'm baking this today, and will post again with results. My issues with the recipe: 1. Weights vs. Volumes: the total amounts are given in both volumetric and weight, but the daily starter additions were only in volume. I had to convert, since Saveur provided no equivalents and differing flour amounts really affect recipes. It appears that they're using either 4.5 or 4.56 ounces per cup of AP Flour and 5 ounces per cup of Bread flour (Cook's Illustrated uses 5 oz for AP. and 5.5 for bread; King Arthur says 4.25 for both.) 2. Number of days: it sounds like it's a total of 9 days, but I had to clarify that by looking at the 2nd step ("On the 10th day"). 3. Vague directions: - Is it 3/4C each of flour and water on days 4 thru 9? It just says, "adding ⅓ cup each water and flour the second and third days and ¾ cup the remaining days". 3/4 cup of what? Do you cover the starter in step 2? Oh, I guess so, since you uncover it in step 3. It's just not written very well.
Oh, and what the heck is meant by amounts like, "4 ¾ cups plus ⅔ cup and 2 tbsp. (1 lb. 9 ⅓ oz.) all-purpose flour"? What? That's 5.54 cups, but the directions only add up to 4.79 cups. There are no directions that call for these 3 separate amounts and I have no clue where the 2 TB comes in. The directions say to start with "¼ cup plus 2 tbsp. all-purpose flour" (3 ounces by volume), then 1/3 cup for 2 days (2/3 Cup or 5.3 ounces by volume), then 3/4 cup for days 4 through 9 (6 ounces x 5 days=30 ounces). That all adds up to 38.3 ounces by volume or 4.79 cups by my calculations, not the 5.54 cups their total comes to. What...?
Just forget it. Avoid this recipe. It's just plain wrong. I finally went to bake it today: 1) dough is too slack, almost like a batter (85% hydration) and 2) starter to dough ratio is off, so it never rises. I worked it as described, let it rise for 3 hours and...nothing. No rise at all. I'm finally adding 3/4 teaspoon of instant yeast and working it in to see if it'll rise. I've now wasted a week and a half of prepping a starter and too much flour to count...all for nothing. I hate you right now, Saveur. I really, really do.
Ha MRMAMBO!!!!

I actually made it but what an ordeal!

Admittedly I kept forgetting about the starter so in reality I was building it for about 15 days. Then the day before I made the second "starter" which I now think you could eliminate. I also omitted the apple cider vinegar and used raisins instead of cranberries.

On like the 700th day, I added more flour, water and salt to the starter,a added raisins and then let it rise. Yes, it had a batter consistency. The recipe called for the flour to hydrate so I figured it would thicken up, but it didn't really. So then I took it out of the bowl and kneaded it with more flour then I put it in a loaf pan and into the cold oven per the recipe.

Then because it called for an another rise in addition to the already 3 hour and 400 days of this recipe, I forgot sbout it until the next afternoon.

It looked like it had risen a little and I just figured I'd bake it and have an ugly loaf. But to my surprise it rose quite a bit and was very moist and tasty ( although the loaf itself is like five pounds).

I will not, however, make this recipe again. I'm moving onto the Filone.

You can see a photo of the loaf here

http://instagr.am/p/K3HAMLF3R0/

Was anyone successful following this recipe as it was printed?! I followed it as written and was totally unsuccessful. I would hope that all Saveur recipes are tested before they are run in the magazine.
noAvatar
Don't you know what levain is?
Here is a definition:
A French word for a natural leaven mixed to a dough-like consistency. A levain is made by adding flour and water or just flour to a "chef". This process is referred to as "building" or "elaborating" the next stage of the leaven.
A levain or levain bread dough is generally fermented at cool temperatures. The firmer consistency and cool temperature fermentation of a levain promotes the development of lactic rather than acidic acids, and a bread leavened with a levain (Pain au Levain) has a rich, complex flavor and is generally not sour. (http://www.angelfire.com/ab/bethsbread/sdDefinitions.html)
Maybe you'd have better luck with the sourdough starter on this link:

http://www.chelseagreen.com/content/recipe-basic-sourdough-starter/

Sandor Katz has just written a new book w/a forward by Michael Pollan
The starter directions are a mess! I had my own starter so skipped that part. Dough is very hydrated yet I was able to bring together using kitchenaid. I do recall it took a good overnight to rise. I attributed to a rather cool 68 deg kitchen. My biggest complaint is 475 degrees for 50 min? I left for work, but had wife bake it off. She pulled out after 22 minutes with the top starting to burn. The bread itself turned out to be quite delicious. I am reattempting today. My plan is to make 2 smaller loaves with the same recipe, and bake at high temp initially, then reduce.
Apple Cider Levain Loaf 2 5 4 11

Your Rating & Review

Please log in to leave a comment. Not a member yet? Sign up here.