Drinks

Friday Cocktails: Horsecar

By Laura Sant


Published on February 22, 2014

I wasn't much of a whiskey drinker until I moved to Chicago, where a regular administration of brown liquor is pretty much a necessity to make it through the winter. At first, my whiskey drinking was strictly utilitarian; one of the bus stops where I'd regularly switch to a different line was also right in front of a bar, so on particularly cold nights I would get off one bus, run inside, shoot some cheap bourbon, and run back across the street before the next bus came, feeling slightly more fortified against the single-digit weather.

It wasn't long, though, before I truly fell in love with the stuff—particularly the peppery bite of rye—and ever since my first Chicago winter I'm automatically drawn to any cocktail that includes it. So when I was flipping through a copy of the 1956 edition of the Esquire Drink Book, the first page I bookmarked was the opener to the "rye and bourbon" section, full of variations on the Manhattan. My favorite was a vermouth-heavy twist called a Horsecar: Instead of the Manhattan's 2:1 ratio of rye to vermouth (in a "Perfect Manhattan", half the vermouth is dry and half is sweet), the Horsecar is equal parts rye, dry vermouth, and sweet vermouth. The result is a sweet-but-not-syrupy cocktail that goes down nicely on a chilly day. Even if you're not trying to make it through a Chicago winter (and if you are, I feel for you), it's the perfect drink to keep you company while you wait patiently for spring's return.

Continue to Next Story

Want more SAVEUR?

Get our favorite recipes, stories, and more delivered to your inbox.