4 Cake Tips - Photo Gallery - Photo 1 | SAVEUR.com

Ben Mims Shares 4 Tips For Baking Better Cakes

Save Gallery Print

Comments (8)

noAvatar
Bleaching LOWERS acidity because bleaching agents are basic, not acidic. The pH scale goes up because bases have higher pH numbers than acids. By the way, this is also why most baking that calls for buttermilk also calls for baking soda in addition to baking powder. The acid in buttermilk is neutralized by the base of the baking soda.
noAvatar
I myself HATE cake flour. I hate the strange after taste (not all can detect it but I can) and the " powdery/cakey" texture. I always replace cake flour based on the same formula listed, that is 1 cup cake flour = 3/4 cup all purpose + 2 tbsp cornstarch. I works all the time and I find it is superior to cake flour.
noAvatar
I had a mess of a time with the Coconut cake from the March Issue. Why no baking powder in the cake flour? Layers were too this to support the frosting..help
merylkoopi@aol.com
noAvatar
please correct my spelling of the word "thin"..wrote "this" by mistake..MK
noAvatar
I just made my go-to vanilla cupcake recipe and modified the flour portion using this tip about reducing the all-purpose flour and adding cornstarch. I have to say that the cupcakes are normally really good but came out much better than only using all-purpose flour. They baked-up nicely, achieved a nice, light golden top. I could feel they were a little lighter in weight and they had a nice delicate, moist texture and good mouth feel. The cornstarch does alter the taste slightly but in a good way. Thanks for the tip.
noAvatar
Actually chlorination lowers pH which means it INCREASES acidity.

The acidity of an ingredient such as cocoa or buttermilk activates the leavening property of the baking soda. You don't add baking soda to balance pH, you add it to a recipe for it's leavening qualities, which are only activated in the presence of an acid ingredient.

Chlorination of cake flours and most soft southern flours not only damages gluten forming proteins but also breaks down starches so they will absorb more water. Cake structure is formed by the foaming of the batter and is supported by the gelatinization of these starches during baking. Higher hydration of batter enables the formation of tiny bubbles to create the air spaces then the starches "lock in" as the cake bakes. Hence the fine structure, small crumb, and tenderness of a cake compared to a bread.

Cake flour, pastry flour, and most southern "biscuit" flours are more finely milled than "regular" AP flours, which contributes to the breakdown of starches. Hence these flours are better suited to biscuits, pancakes, cakes, etc.
noAvatar
Adding corn starch to "regular" AP flour is an attempt to mimic the desirable qualities of a finely milled soft cake flour by introducing starch and increasing the maximum possible hydration of the batter. It generally does give better results than using unmodified AP flour, but cake flour is still noticeably better. You may further approach the qualities of cake flour by using a heat treatment (search for "Kate Flour" for more information) and by the addition of emulsifiers such as Xanthan gum.

In a cake batter, Xanthan gum not only acts as an emulsifier, it also affects viscosity - by increasing viscosity it supports the formation of the foaming properties of the batter, resulting in a lighter end product.

Personally I'd prefer to just use chlorinated cake flour but at about 3 times the cost of White Lily AP (not self-rising) I seldom use it. I get results approaching those of actual cake flour from the more finely milled, slightly chlorinated White Lily, and better than from "regular" AP flours such as Pillsbury or Gold Medal, without having to resort to heat treatment or additives.
noAvatar
Meryl, try reducing the butter to 1/2c (from 1 cup)
Reduce eggs to 2 whole eggs and one yolk
change to table salt
use buttermilk or 1/2c plain yogurt mixed with 1/2c milk (stir well or whisk to mix, to make a smooth mixture)
You may actually get better results by switching from butter to shortening
Shortening supports the structure of light cakes better than butter - if you want a lighter loftier cake shortening supports that because it is a solid at room temp.

If you still don't get the results you want you can try changing to 2 tsp double acting baking powder from the 1 tsp of baking soda. The baking soda, with the acid ingredient of the buttermilk, should be fine, though. One thing you could try (though it honestly shouldn't be necessary) is to reserve 1 T of the buttermilk and the baking soda til the end, then quickly whisk the two together (I have a teensy whisk for tasks like this) and gently stir this into the batter. DO NOT OVERSTIR the batter at any stage, it will make it dense.

In any case it is important to pan and bake immediately - cakes generally have a 2 stage leavening process where there is some leavening at room temp and then additional leavening at oven temps. If too much time passes between mixing in the chemical leavener and getting the pan into the oven, you will lose the advantages of that first stage of leavening - it will "poop out".

Your Comments

Please log in to leave a comment. Not a member yet? Sign up here.