If you had stopped by our test kitchen yesterday, you would have happened upon Max and Eli Sussman, cooking like mad, all burners going, ingredients piled on every available surface. The chefs and authors of Classic Recipes for Modern People were here to prepare an early Passover feast, cohosted by their parents—a meal to forever be known as the best seder ever.

For many of us, the meal was also our first seder ever, so Max & Eli’s father Marc and mother Lynn were there to guide us through their family’s rituals and traditions. “We do weird things with our food,” Marc Sussman joked. Whatever they did, it was delicious. Check out the highlights—and all that crazy-delicious food—below.

Max and Eli arrived early in the morning to start prepping for the feast—which of course included matzo ball soup. Here, Max forms the dumplings for their version of the soup, which included braised oxtail. Michelle Heimerman
Eli stirring the same lamb stew that his dad makes every Passover, full of chickpeas, greens, apricots, and dates. (No word on whether his dad also wears a Fresh Prince of Bel Air–inspired hat while doing it.) Matthew Taylor-Gross
The secret to great Instagrams? Having Williams-Sonoma style your table certainly doesn’t hurt. Michelle Heimerman
Gefilte Fish Terrine
The prettiest gefilte fish you’ve ever seen: Max & Eli’s gefilte fish terrine, which was passed around before the meal began. Michelle Heimerman
Max Sussman plating crispy artichokes
Max Sussman plating crispy artichokes with miso aioli, a dish from their cookbook inspired by their mom’s intense love of artichokes. Michelle Heimerman
No one is safe from @sachsmo: Editor in chief Adam Sachs makes Max pose for an Instagram. Michelle Heimerman
Carrot and pistachio salad
The second dish of the night: A slightly bitter, slightly sweet, entirely addictive carrot and pistachio salad. Michelle Heimerman
The brothers hard at work. Michelle Heimerman
Max, Eli, and Marc Sussman
Every year, Marc designates a theme for his seder. Last year’s theme revolved around the question, “Who would you invite to your seder?” Our answer to that one, obviously, is the Sussman family. (Same time next year, guys?) Michelle Heimerman
Eli Sussman and Marc Sussman
As the youngest child, Eli was always tasked with reading the four questions, an important part of the Passover seder. This seder was no different; Marc put him to work before the food was served. “The classic joke goes, there aren’t four questions, there are five,” said Marc. “And the fifth one is, ‘when do we eat?'” Michelle Heimerman
Eli and Marc Sussman
Like father, like son: similar maror-tasting faces; similar taste in stylish headwear. Michelle Heimerman
Max and Eli Sussman's Salmon with Chermoula
Max plating salmon with chermoula and sautéed vegetables, a recipe based on their mom’s oven-broiled salmon. Overheard at the table: “I want to put that chermoula on everything. Cereal included.” Michelle Heimerman
Gorgeous seder table, gorgeous guests. Michelle Heimerman
“At this point in the dinner, Uncle Al has long since fallen asleep,” Marc says, which means it’s time for a fourth glass of wine and mom’s macaroons. Michelle Heimerman
Vanilla almond mousse with chocolate pecan matzo
After macaroons, the second dessert: Vanilla almond mousse with chocolate pecan matzo. “Just…a lot of wow,” said our copy chief upon tasting it. Michelle Heimerman
Poached pears in Fernet, the third and final dessert of the night. Matthew Taylor-Gross
Max and Eli Sussman's Passover Seder
The whole seder crew: Marc Sussman, Amy Marr from Weldon-Owen, Eli Sussman, editor-in-chief Adam Sachs, Max Sussman, and SAVEUR’s Stefanie McNamara. Michelle Heimerman