These six sundaes (in unexpected combinations like vanilla topped with olive oil and fresh figs, or coffee draped with sweetened condensed milk and cocoa nibs) have all the satisfaction—and sophistication—of a homemade treat, but they’re dead-simple to put together.

Vanilla Ice Cream, Smoked Almonds, and Chocolate Sauce

Coffee Ice Cream, Sweetened Condensed Milk, and Cocoa Nibs

Coconut Ice Cream, Crushed Sesame Candies, and Salty Caramel Sauce

Vanilla Ice Cream, Chopped Fresh Figs, Olive Oil Drizzle, and Sea Salt

Chocolate Ice Cream, Puffed Rice, and Marshmallow Sauce

Strawberry Ice Cream, Crushed Graham Crackers, Sliced Bananas, and Whipped Cream