Our 16 Best Thanksgiving Dessert Recipes That Aren't Pie

Think outside the crust

By SAVEUR Editors
October 31, 2017

When you think of Thanksgiving, the first dessert that probably comes to mind is a picture-perfect fall pie. But some of our best sweet Thanksgiving recipes don't have a crust at all. These surprising desserts like squash pudding cooked in a cast-iron skillet or a pumpkin cake will prove that you don't need pie as your final bite at the Thanksgiving feast. Top off your meal with our best Thanksgiving dessert recipes that aren't pie.

Oatmeal Creme Pies with Vanilla Marshmallow Creme

Oatmeal Creme Pies with Vanilla Marshmallow Creme
Ground, dried apple slices folded into the dough give these cookies their characteristic bouncy texture. Get the recipe for Oatmeal Creme Pies with Vanilla Marshmallow Creme »Kat Craddock

Almond-Cardamom Pakhlava

almond-cardamom pakhlava
At Zulya Kazimova's bakery in Baku, pakhlava—the Azeri version of baklava, which she cuts into a diamond shape—is made using 14 layers of a dense yeasted dough rolled out so thinly and painstakingly that it becomes translucent. Get the recipe for Almond-Cardamom Pakhlava »Jason Lang

Cast-Iron Squash Pudding

cast-iron squash pudding
This luscious, cakelike pudding, made with milk-poached butternut squash batter and crowned with caramel-drenched delicata, rides the line perfectly between side dish and dessert, "kind of like yams with marshmallows," says Joe Beef's Red Morin, who serves it with caramel sauce or sweetened whipped cream. Get the recipe for Cast-Iron Squash Pudding »Christina Holmes

Wood-Roasted Apples with Burnt Cinnamon Caramel

cinnamon caramel roasted apples
Cooking time will vary according to the apple variety you choose, but be sure to use a sturdy, very tart apple such as Honeycrisp or Zestar. The smokiness and char from the wood fire, together with the theater of roasting apples over the hot coals, really makes this dessert, but in a pinch you can roast the apples on a baking sheet at 400° uncovered for 30–35 minutes. Get the recipe for Wood-Roasted Apples with Burnt Cinnamon Caramel »Michelle Heimerman

Cornbread Coffee Cake with Fresh Figs and Walnut Streusel

Cornbread Coffee Cake with Fresh Figs and Walnut Streusel
Southern chef Vivian Howard developed this cake with breakfast in mind, maybe something to share with family over coffee. But when she first made it, her kids named it corn-candy cake and called for it after supper. She obliged and put some whipped cream on top. Whenever you choose to eat it, feel good about baking it a day ahead. It keeps beautifully and is as satisfying at room temperature as it is warm. Get the recipe for Cornbread Coffee Cake with Fresh Figs and Walnut Streusel »Tim Robison

Dried Apricot and Fig Clafoutis with Rum

Fruit Cake Clafoutis
Clafoutis is a French dessert that's trickier to pronounce than to make. A simple mixture of flour, eggs, dairy, and a little sugar, it's like a pancake, but more custardy, and it's baked instead of griddled. It looks and tastes impressive the way classic French desserts often do, but it's simple enough to whip up any weeknight. Rum-soaked dried apricots, figs, and raisins add their caramelized and honeyed flavors to this creamy version, perfect for cold weather when there's no fresh fruit around. Get the recipe for Dried Apricot and Fig Clafoutis with Rum »Matt Taylor-Gross

Honey-and-Butter-Baked Pears with Cold Cream

Honey-and-Butter Baked Pears with Cold Cream
These sticky, caramelized pears get served warm with a glug of fresh chilled cream for a richly-flavored variation on poached pears. Get the recipe for Honey-and-Butter-Baked Pears with Cold Cream »Anders Schonnemann

Mango and Pumpkin Spice Cake

Pumpkin Mango Cake, Senegalese Thanksgiving
Fresh mango, mixed into the base and fanned on top of this warmly spiced pumpkin dessert—chef Pierre Thiam's version of his wife's classic pumpkin cake—adds a tropical brightness and dramatic presentation to his Thanksgiving table. Get the recipe for Mango and Pumpkin Spice Cake »Ryan Liebe

Pumpkin Spoon Halva with Cardamom Syrup

Pumpkin Spoon Halva with Cardamom Syrup
Just three ingredients—pumpkin, coconut milk, and salt—combine to make a simple spoon pudding, sweetened with cardamom-scented golden syrup and topped with crunchy pumpkin seeds. Get the recipe for Pumpkin Spoon Halva with Cardamom Syrup »Farideh Sadeghin

Peptia-Sage Brittle

Pepita-Sage Brittle
Use this bittersweet caramel brittle as a topping to kick up store-bought pumpkin pie—substitute dried coconut flakes and chopped macadamia nuts to pair with a Key lime pie, or dried lavender and slivered almonds for a chocolate cream pie. It also makes a great gift: a fall party favor, wrapped in cellophane and handed off as your guests make their exit. Get the recipe for Peptia-Sage Brittle »Matt Taylor-Gross

Maple Pot de Crème

Maple Pot de Crème
Creamy custard sweetened with maple syrup makes a lovely ending to any meal. Get the recipe for Maple Pot de Crème »Todd Coleman

Pear Tarte Tatin

Pear Tarte Tatin
This tart is traditionally made with apples, but firm-fleshed pears make a delicate and delicious alternative. Get the recipe for Pear Tarte Tatin »Vanessa Rees

Apple and Cranberry Upside-Down Cakes

Apple and Cranberry Upside-Down Cakes
If you find yourself with a surplus of fresh cranberries, these elegant cakes are the perfect solution. They can be cooked in individual miniature pans, or in a single skillet for convenience. Get the recipe for Apple and Cranberry Upside-Down Cakes »Khushbu Shah

Pumpkin and Bourbon Mousse

Pumpkin and Bourbon Mousse
All the traditional flavors of pumpkin pie combine in this satisfying, creamy mousse. Get the recipe for Pumpkin and Bourbon Mousse »Todd Coleman

Pumpkin Cheesecake

Pumpkin Cheesecake
Rum and gingersnaps add a spicy, warming flavor to this rich fall dessert. Get the recipe for Pumpkin Cheesecake »Beth Rooney

Spice Applesauce Cake

applesauce cake recipe
Applesauce adds moisture and sweet apple flavor in a lovely cinnamon-spiced, autumnal cake. Get the recipe for Spice Applesauce Cake »Tim Mazurek

Latest

BVI-Style Peas Soup
Boozy and Easy
Saag Paneer Is the Luscious Indian Comfort Food You Need
A Hearty (Caribbean!) Soup to Get You Through The Winter
Lalla Rookh Pie
Seattle Scotch Is A Thing. And It’s Good.
Mardi Gras King Cake
Saag Paneer (Spinach with Fresh Indian Cheese)
Banish Kitchen Clutter with Five Genius Fridge Organizers
ADVERTISEMENT / ADVERTISE WITH US